First of all, what exactly is the use of force? You may think the title pretty much explain itself, but let’s dig a little deeper. The use of force can be defined as when you use strength or a certain force you are in possession of, and imply it in other people, stuff or situations. It’s having the power to have something done and use it. Let’s talk about person to person use of force. As mostly everything, the use of force has two sides to be considered: the person implying the force (person 1) and the person who it’s implied to (person 2). Sometimes the person 1 doesn’t need to use the “use of force” on person 2, and it becomes unfair, because things can have been done a better way, where person 2 didn’t need to suffer the way it did. But we have a second case, where person 2 needs something, somethings that has to be done. When person 2 imposes to receive or do what it need to, it’s actually using the use of force, and this leaves person 1 with no other choice but to use the use of force on person 2. In the story “The use of force” by William Carlos William there’s a combined case of the two discussed before. Here, we can see a doctor who is not in the best behavior or attitude toward the patient and a patient who strongly refuses to being examined by a doctor. When you read the story you think “Wow, that doctor is so imprudent and what he did was totally unnecessary”; but what about the girls attitude? She was obviously depriving the doctor from doing his job and she knew she was sick, but she still was a stuck up and didn’t cooperate when she had to, when it was all for her own health. So the doctor had to do what he had to for the little girls’ health and wellbeing. But, we can all agree that he took it a little to the extreme, for example, he saw that the girl was bleeding and he didn’t stop the pressure and force he was using on her. He even says, “But the worst of it was that I too had got beyond reason. I could have torn the child apart in my own fury and enjoyed it. It was a pleasure to attack her. My face was burning with it.” He wanted to use the use of force, knowing her parents will agree being afraid she was dying, to see her hurt, to hear her screams and he could feel he had the power in the situation. I don’t know about you, but for me that’s a little psychotic. They both were wrong, and by implying the use of force they made the situation a lot worse. So in general, is the use of force really necessary, or is it much easier if both parties cooperate and have a peaceful agreement upon the situation?
Este comentario ha sido eliminado por el autor.
ResponderEliminarMan you got every single thought I would've said but, the thing is that the question was "Was there a use of force or a use of violence?" But this is good I suggest you leave as it is.
ResponderEliminarThe violence was unnecessary, rape like. The doctor enjoyed it. I dint like the doctor's way of "treating" the patient.
ResponderEliminarFor me, in this story the use of force was necessary until some point. Not that I agree with the doctor's methods, but at the end the cause was very important.
ResponderEliminarEste comentario ha sido eliminado por el autor.
ResponderEliminarHello Jeanette! In this particular case I like how you present your analysis of the use of force or violence in the short story, however I'm in favor of the child, even if she was being unreasonable she was scared of being diagnosed and the doctor did nothing to appease the child... it would've saved him a lot of time and effort.
ResponderEliminar~~~Paula
Really well covering most aspect of the short story. I would like to comment on the parent’s role in the story. I feel that they allowed everything to take place, but only because of them being in the low social class. We can see how the parents can only afford to give the doctor a few dollars. Anyway, do you believe that the parents allowed this use of force to take place? ( especially the father, because he is the head of the family and although he suffers as he sees his girl suffer, he knows it is for her own good.)
ResponderEliminar